Customer Rating: 
Summary: Echoes of Nature - Humpback Whales
Comment: Whales, too, know good and bad times, passion and boredom. If an opera singer doesn't deliver full peformance, you'd blame them for lack of enthusiasm or discipline. If a recording with whalesongs isn't overly exciting however, it isn't the fault of the animals, but that of the scientist who got them on an uninspired mood or a bad day.This is the case with the "Echoes of Nature" edition of humpback whale songs, which features a single track of 1 hour length. The communications shown here are somewhat monotonous, almost free from dramatic whines and cries and wall-shaking grunts, and you get the idea you're listening to everyday chit-chat.
It doesn't help with the analysis of the recording that the booklet contains no whatsoever information. This is just unprofessional and decreases research value. Who recorded? When and where? How many animals, what was their situation, and what other species do I hear in the background?
Ergo: only of interest for fans that need even the ultimate facette and timbre. These should pay attention to the strangely weak-ish and playful passage during the first few minutes and to the highly unusual sounds from 24:20 to about 26:30, where razor-like hums and deep growls seem to have a conversation, to be joined by weird hiccups.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Amazing musicians!
Comment: We loved this CD! It is relaxing, happy, peaceful. Underwater opera, master musicians, complex vocalizations, playful, joyful, rich, repeated phrases sliding up and down the scale in perfect harmony. See if you can pick out the baby whale who joins in with his attempts to imitate the big whales, and listen to how the other whales react. Inspirational! I am buying this CD for my granddaughter's first birthday.
Customer Rating:
Summary: In a world of beautiful sound, why choose the ugly?
Comment: I was really disappointed with this CD. I wasn't expecting much - environmental CD's tend to be like wine, the more you pay the better the quality. I purchased this to stock up on whale song samples (long story, don't ask) but this one I played once and promptly put back into the CD shelf where its been gathering dust.I've only sold a used CD of mine 3 times, many years ago, but this one actually has me thinking about dropping by my local Used CD store to pick up a buck or two in store credit.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Simple & clear not bored
Comment: I got the this, few days ago. I have listened several whale's recording. This CD contain so clear sound of humpback. There are simple and repeated tune, but not bored. In conclusion, Simple & clear & beautiful!
